Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Jul 24, 8:23 AM
#1
Offline
Aug 2023
3
So I watched episode 2 and thought it was so bad that I couldn't get through the last few minutes of the episode. It really felt like a confirmation that everything that could go wrong with this show would go wrong. Spoilers for episode 2.

- Every girl in existence falls madly in love with the edgelord MC because he's just so cool
- The edgelord MC resolves every incident while using his super intelligence to totally school all the fools around him

These are the two things that need to not be true for the show to be good, but episode 2 had them on full display. What especially sickened me was that the king is portrayed as a fool because he tried to make his daughter get married. Excuse him for prioritizing the stability of the realm over the feelings of one girl. Isn't the princess actually tyrannical for putting her own feelings above the wellbeing of the nation?

But what REALLY, REALLY bothers me is how this girl is then called a "nice person" for... trying to kill herself in order to throw her kingdom into chaos, an act which would condemn an untold number of innocents to suffering and/or death, all because she doesn't really wanna fulfill her duties... but then she CHANGED HER MIND at the last second! What a nice gal!

And then Shadow the Hedgehog beats the big monster because he's just so cool. The princess is put in charge, because she has just such a good track record when it comes to making decisions, while her father, humiliated from his MISTAKE of requiring her to have obligations, has to stand to the side in disgrace.

So this episode convinced me that all my worst fears about the show were confirmed. The suicidal protagonist is portrayed as a wise and courageous antihero, everyone he meets is deeply fascinated by him, and he saves the day by taking action while everyone else looks on in amazement. The message of episode 2 is that parents are just such stupid idiots when they try to make you do stuff, and I really can't help but wonder if this says something about the author.

But I do wonder if I was just overreacting. Am I wrong for dropping this?
Jul 24, 8:45 AM
#2

Offline
Jul 2015
11869
Is this your first isekai or something?

Jul 24, 8:48 AM
#3
Offline
Oct 2020
616
This is a parody, this is parodying the isekai genre, and you seem to be taking it too seriously, that's the problem, nothing else

But seeing as you don't have much anime in your list, come back to this when you have watched way more isekai's, then you will actually appreciate the show
Jul 24, 8:51 AM
#4
Negator

Online
Mar 2022
735
I think if you aren’t enjoying something, it’s valid to drop it. It is what it is, don’t force yourself to indulge in something you don’t like. That being said, I’ll just add this picture here. The manga for some reason doesn’t have the parody tag, but regardless a main part of the comedy seems to be making fun of common isekai tropes. By of course playing into the tropes. If you don’t like that, that’s fine
Jul 24, 8:53 AM
#5
Offline
May 2011
1103
Absolutely not. If you're not enjoying an anime, dropping it is the logical action take.
Jul 24, 8:54 AM
#6
Offline
May 2023
84
WhiteForAReason said:
So I watched episode 2 and thought it was so bad that I couldn't get through the last few minutes of the episode. It really felt like a confirmation that everything that could go wrong with this show would go wrong. Spoilers for episode 2.

- Every girl in existence falls madly in love with the edgelord MC because he's just so cool
- The edgelord MC resolves every incident while using his super intelligence to totally school all the fools around him

These are the two things that need to not be true for the show to be good, but episode 2 had them on full display. What especially sickened me was that the king is portrayed as a fool because he tried to make his daughter get married. Excuse him for prioritizing the stability of the realm over the feelings of one girl. Isn't the princess actually tyrannical for putting her own feelings above the wellbeing of the nation?

But what REALLY, REALLY bothers me is how this girl is then called a "nice person" for... trying to kill herself in order to throw her kingdom into chaos, an act which would condemn an untold number of innocents to suffering and/or death, all because she doesn't really wanna fulfill her duties... but then she CHANGED HER MIND at the last second! What a nice gal!

And then Shadow the Hedgehog beats the big monster because he's just so cool. The princess is put in charge, because she has just such a good track record when it comes to making decisions, while her father, humiliated from his MISTAKE of requiring her to have obligations, has to stand to the side in disgrace.

So this episode convinced me that all my worst fears about the show were confirmed. The suicidal protagonist is portrayed as a wise and courageous antihero, everyone he meets is deeply fascinated by him, and he saves the day by taking action while everyone else looks on in amazement. The message of episode 2 is that parents are just such stupid idiots when they try to make you do stuff, and I really can't help but wonder if this says something about the author.

But I do wonder if I was just overreacting. Am I wrong for dropping this?

This show is not meant to be taken seriously
Jul 24, 8:55 AM
#7
Offline
Feb 2021
127
You’re never “wrong” for dropping a show. If, for whatever reason, you wanna stop watching something, you have every right to do so.

However, I DO think you’re overreacting somewhat. The show is a comedy, one about a dude whose desire to die is matched only by his ability to live. The feats he accomplishes and the reputation it gives him are footnotes, missteps even, on the road to his suicide.

Of course, it being a comedy doesn’t mean you HAVE to find it funny, but the show clearly isn’t taking itself seriously, and, whether you continue to watch it or not, I don’t think you should either.
Jul 24, 9:10 AM
#8
Offline
Aug 2022
282
WhiteForAReason said:
So I watched episode 2 and thought it was so bad that I couldn't get through the last few minutes of the episode. It really felt like a confirmation that everything that could go wrong with this show would go wrong. Spoilers for episode 2.

- Every girl in existence falls madly in love with the edgelord MC because he's just so cool
- The edgelord MC resolves every incident while using his super intelligence to totally school all the fools around him

These are the two things that need to not be true for the show to be good, but episode 2 had them on full display. What especially sickened me was that the king is portrayed as a fool because he tried to make his daughter get married. Excuse him for prioritizing the stability of the realm over the feelings of one girl. Isn't the princess actually tyrannical for putting her own feelings above the wellbeing of the nation?

But what REALLY, REALLY bothers me is how this girl is then called a "nice person" for... trying to kill herself in order to throw her kingdom into chaos, an act which would condemn an untold number of innocents to suffering and/or death, all because she doesn't really wanna fulfill her duties... but then she CHANGED HER MIND at the last second! What a nice gal!

And then Shadow the Hedgehog beats the big monster because he's just so cool. The princess is put in charge, because she has just such a good track record when it comes to making decisions, while her father, humiliated from his MISTAKE of requiring her to have obligations, has to stand to the side in disgrace.

So this episode convinced me that all my worst fears about the show were confirmed. The suicidal protagonist is portrayed as a wise and courageous antihero, everyone he meets is deeply fascinated by him, and he saves the day by taking action while everyone else looks on in amazement. The message of episode 2 is that parents are just such stupid idiots when they try to make you do stuff, and I really can't help but wonder if this says something about the author.

But I do wonder if I was just overreacting. Am I wrong for dropping this?

bro if you want to know about Osamu Dazai story then hear me out
Osamu Dazai was a novelist and he wrote a book called "No Longer Human" which is basically his biography and the book is adapted in anime form in "Blue Literature" you don't have to watch whole 12 episode series just watch episode 1-4 named no longer human other episodes are different stories written by different writers.
I think that the story of Osamu Dazai is really dark and interesting that you have to watch yourself to find out
Jul 24, 9:52 AM
#9
Offline
Nov 2018
1075
If it's something you don't see yourself not liking, then drop it. I at least try to give the majority of the season a try before sorting out what I'm going to watch and what I don't like.
Jul 24, 9:56 AM
Offline
Jan 2022
292
Fail_Man_X said:
Absolutely not. If you're not enjoying an anime, dropping it is the logical action take.

honestly people need to embrace this. not all content is for all people and that's okay
Jul 24, 10:09 AM

Offline
Apr 2021
1352
No. You don't like it, you don't watch it. Simple.
Jul 24, 10:10 AM
Offline
Dec 2022
815
yes you are wrong for dropping.

it seems like you haven't watched many isekai( under the assumption that this is your real account ). Will they say most isekai's are trash, for no reason. maby isekai isn't for you. but still wondering if you rated shadow gardens an 8/10, what's so hard about watching this.

Anyway if something is too hard/unbearable to watch. it's better it to drop it or put it on hold and watch it after a long period of time .
Yeshaiah2015yeshJul 24, 10:28 AM
Jul 24, 10:32 AM
Offline
Aug 2023
4
Everyone has different tastes on the type of anime, if you don't enjoy it just drop it.
Bear in mind that anime does not make logical and practical sense, especially animes from the isekai, ecchi, and harem genre.
Jul 24, 11:06 AM

Offline
Mar 2021
2972
CrunchyCrobat said:
This is a parody, this is parodying the isekai genre, and you seem to be taking it too seriously, that's the problem, nothing else

But seeing as you don't have much anime in your list, come back to this when you have watched way more isekai's, then you will actually appreciate the show

That should have been way obvious when a fucking truck comes and rams over the MC in the first few minutes of the premiere during the double suicide scene. The MC's name is Osamu fucking Dazai. And cherry on top is the title of the anime "Isekai Shikkaku"/"No longer allowed in another world" which is a reference to one of Osamu Dazai's books "Ningen Shikkaku"/"No longer Human"
V1P3R0PAug 1, 12:20 AM
Jul 24, 11:35 AM
Offline
Apr 2024
77
I think he will NOT like Konosuba 😭😭
Jul 24, 11:37 AM
Offline
Apr 2024
77
this looks like a fake acc tbh only 25 entrys or they are new to anime
Jul 24, 12:36 PM
Offline
May 2022
805
Yes. The producers will find you and throw you out of a window. Your family too.
Jul 24, 12:42 PM
Offline
Jan 2022
106
if u are dropping this after ep 2 than u are not a isakai guy, so don't watch other isakai shows as well...
Jul 24, 1:07 PM
Offline
Oct 2022
72
Yes bro, you're overreacting. I will just leave it at that, Everyone's mindset is different.

And no, you're not wrong for dropping it. if you can't bear watching it or don't like something in the anime then you should definitely drop it.
Jul 24, 2:03 PM
Offline
Dec 2022
1425
Your anime entry list says a lot about you. Like some said above, the anime is PARODY. You get that? PARODY. And I am not even watching the anime since I heard it is gonna be dubbed but I am reading and have caught up to the manga. One thing I'll tell you is that if you do decide to drop this anime, you are dropping a hidden gem.

That is all I'll say.
Jul 25, 6:30 AM
Awkward Fellow

Offline
Oct 2018
1629
If you’re not enjoying it, drop it. No need to seek validation from or try to influence others.

Personally it’s one of my favorite shows this season & I think it’s one of the funnier isekai parodies I’ve seen.
OhayotakuJul 25, 6:45 AM
Jul 25, 10:01 AM

Offline
Apr 2021
278
This shit is lame, his book is not a great read either.
Jul 25, 10:47 AM
Offline
Jun 2021
57
idk, because i actually enjoyed the 2nd episode ( and every other episode that's out). This is just a casual isekai that's a bit different to most. i think the anime is executed really well and is great, but if you wana drop it, then do it. it doesn't change my opinion on it. if you dont like something, then drop it and watch smt else.
Jul 25, 12:36 PM
Offline
Oct 2022
144
CrunchyCrobat said:
This is a parody, this is parodying the isekai genre, and you seem to be taking it too seriously, that's the problem, nothing else

But seeing as you don't have much anime in your list, come back to this when you have watched way more isekai's, then you will actually appreciate the show

Spot on here.. I think a lot of people are struggling with understanding this one. Personally I think it’s a HUGE breath of fresh air. It’s hilarious, ridiculous, and completely insane and that’s what makes it so good. People need to understand that the Mc doesn’t give a f$&@. He wants to die with the woman he loves and nothing is going to stop him. If he has to kidnap and sell a busload of nuns to a brothel that’s what he’s going to do. He’s not a hero and he doesn’t want to be.
Jul 26, 5:11 AM
Offline
Jan 2023
12
I wanted to drop it bc I don't watch much Isekai and the fact that it's a parody went completely over my head hahaha, now it actually seems funny? I was wondering why they were using such cooked CGI but now it makes sense, I guess if you're not familiar with the tropes of a certain genre then something like this would be hard to digest
Jul 26, 8:00 AM
Offline
Feb 2023
7
WhiteForAReason said:
So I watched episode 2 and thought it was so bad that I couldn't get through the last few minutes of the episode. It really felt like a confirmation that everything that could go wrong with this show would go wrong. Spoilers for episode 2.

- Every girl in existence falls madly in love with the edgelord MC because he's just so cool
- The edgelord MC resolves every incident while using his super intelligence to totally school all the fools around him

These are the two things that need to not be true for the show to be good, but episode 2 had them on full display. What especially sickened me was that the king is portrayed as a fool because he tried to make his daughter get married. Excuse him for prioritizing the stability of the realm over the feelings of one girl. Isn't the princess actually tyrannical for putting her own feelings above the wellbeing of the nation?

But what REALLY, REALLY bothers me is how this girl is then called a "nice person" for... trying to kill herself in order to throw her kingdom into chaos, an act which would condemn an untold number of innocents to suffering and/or death, all because she doesn't really wanna fulfill her duties... but then she CHANGED HER MIND at the last second! What a nice gal!

And then Shadow the Hedgehog beats the big monster because he's just so cool. The princess is put in charge, because she has just such a good track record when it comes to making decisions, while her father, humiliated from his MISTAKE of requiring her to have obligations, has to stand to the side in disgrace.

So this episode convinced me that all my worst fears about the show were confirmed. The suicidal protagonist is portrayed as a wise and courageous antihero, everyone he meets is deeply fascinated by him, and he saves the day by taking action while everyone else looks on in amazement. The message of episode 2 is that parents are just such stupid idiots when they try to make you do stuff, and I really can't help but wonder if this says something about the author.

But I do wonder if I was just overreacting. Am I wrong for dropping this?

U can drop any anime that u feel not interesting.
Jul 26, 9:27 AM

Offline
Mar 2017
119
It's called overthinking, not overreacting. Most of the time, it leads you to really weird thoughts, instead of the best conclusion. Wondering if something totally unimportant was wrong or not, is a symptom of it.
Jul 26, 8:04 PM
Offline
Apr 2023
88
Idk I mean sounds like a normal issikai but it’s more so a comedy, although your never wrong in dropping somthing if you truely don’t like it
Jul 26, 11:45 PM
Offline
Aug 2020
101
There's nothing wrong with dropping something you don't want to watch anymore. You also don't need to take every gag seriously. Most gags are meant to be stupid so that they will be funny. Unless some author can do it in a smarter way, Also, it wasn't as edgy as Arifureta or Failure Frame. It was just a chill dude wanting to die.
Jul 30, 7:54 PM
Offline
Aug 2023
3
A lot of people have suggested that I'm new to isekai or anime in general, but this is just a new account. I have a giant stack of isekai LNs that I've read, and I'm honestly a bit of an isekai fanatic. I even liked the vending machine anime. I only started this account because keeping track of all the anime I'm watching was becoming a pain.
Jul 30, 8:47 PM
Offline
Oct 2019
7005
Does bro doesn't understand parody comedy?
Jul 31, 8:24 AM

Offline
Jul 2015
1699
I dropped it too. It's not bad or unbearable, and I don't mind the comedy/parody aspects. It just doesn't have something compelling enough to keep me engaged for 12 episodes (~3 months). Maybe I'll give it another shot in the future if the feedback is overwhelmingly positive, but I highly doubt it.
Jul 31, 8:30 AM
Offline
May 2022
55
What If I said your are wrong for dropping? Will you pick it up again probably no? We are like 8 Billion different minded people in this world, every single person has something uncommon to others. So yeah u did nothing wrong but one thing I can say it's gets better as story progresses (take this as my opinion).
Anyways I am a manga reader.
So, I know the story about this one and it's better and intresting to see for me.
Even I hope to see another season.. Lol.
Jul 31, 9:28 AM

Offline
Dec 2016
1325
OP, you're not going to get reasonable or even at least decent replies in here. The bottom of the barrel users in this site will patronize you and educate because you don't coomsume the trash they do and think it's normal for them (making you the weird one).

Isekai trash plays the "iTs a pArODy aBoUt iSeKai" card so often that it just stops being a parody and it's just a shitposting anime with an isekai angle. These people need to understand that comedy and parodies aren't free of criticism and there needs to be some bigger narrative or message at the end of all this non sense, but a lot of these cheap vapor wave "isekai parodies" don't, because they are cheap to produce and quick to sell (it's the low hanging fruit). Just look at something like Family Guy that aired for literally years, it was so polarizing between hardcore fans and hard critics, but even even among the biggest fans plenty of people acknowledges that a lot of it's jokes either go to far or are just too stretched out but no one in my personal experience has played "oh it's a parody of something" and use it as some get out of jail card.

WhiteForAReason said:
The suicidal protagonist is portrayed as a wise and courageous antihero, everyone he meets is deeply fascinated by him, and he saves the day by taking action while everyone else looks on in amazement.


I pretty much saw this coming since episode 1. It made me eyeroll so hard when some of the users in here said "oh this is such a refreshing isekai" when it does exactly as every other trash isekai does by making a powerful protag that will have loyal followers despite him not even caring about them. Like I said, don't expect good reasoning in here when it comes to dissecting garbage isekai.
Jul 31, 11:13 AM

Offline
Mar 2017
119
Actually, the biggest flag OP should be careful with are replies that attack other opinions. Reading them would fuel your overthinking tendency to no end.
Jul 31, 1:07 PM
Offline
Apr 2024
92
I am only 2 episodes in, and I already thinking about dropping this. Even though I've watched a lot of anime, some about isekai, but that doesn't mean I know what to exact or have any expectation at all. But I'll say I always try to be open minded, even though sometimes I don't agree with the plot or the messages it might trying to send. Afterall, this is an anime, and I won't take it too seriously. It is what it is.
Aug 7, 6:15 PM

Offline
May 2022
445
I am having so much fun with this show. I think each episodes is more delightful than the one before it so maybe give it another go.
9 hours ago

Offline
Sep 2015
681
I watched to episode 5 and also am considering dropping it. It is a parody but while it is entertaining enough, the jokes aren't making me laugh that much. I find the idea interesting with Dazai and everything. The main issue I see as someone(who is much more critical of the show) else pointed out is that the Isekai genre have so many bad ones that trying to parody the genre by going to the extreme on the tropes just won't work. But as others have said, it's hard for you to judge without watching other Isekais first.

Normally when you parody a trope, you can invert viewer expectations or just turn it up to 11 so it's absolutely ridiculous to kind of make a statement. However the latter is already slowly becoming the standard of non-parody isekai. When normal isekai is already leaning super heavily onto these tropes, it's hard to parody them by trying to be even more ridiculous. Which is what i see the main failing of this show. Rather than making fun of the tropes, it feels like just another isekai in practice. The parody aspect is only obvious with the main character's motivation and lack of concern for everything else.

Also despite being a parody, you need character development and a decent plot. The plot idea by episode 4-5 is pretty interesting but that's quite far in to start selling the show most of the time. It might end up good but with how it has started off, I wouldn't put my hopes up. Overall the ideas are there but the execution isn't really up to snuff I think.

In this sense, it might be best to watch good Isekai and then watch this. You might enjoy it then because it plays on those tropes to a extreme degree relative to the more measured examples. But if you watch a lot of mediocre isekai, this might feel too similar to those to be funny as in practice they aren't too different and thus not enough for the parody to work.

Konosuba is another parody but takes the inversion route. Where all the tropes appear but it never ends up how the viewer (or the main character for that matter) expects it to. IMO Konosuba is the far better parody and also maintains character development throughout the story, albeit its a slow burn development. Interactions are also more organic which helps the characters break out of their tropes. (not walking tropes)
zcv459 hours ago

More topics from this board

Poll: » Isekai Shikkaku Episode 6 Discussion

Stark700 - Yesterday

30 by OtakuKun1 »»
2 hours ago

» The author must be very drunk when they wrote this story

fraz15 - Aug 10

11 by MegamiRem »»
6 hours ago

Poll: » Isekai Shikkaku Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Jul 30

57 by MegamiRem »»
6 hours ago

Poll: » Isekai Shikkaku Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Jul 23

60 by NonSenseWILH »»
6 hours ago

Poll: » Isekai Shikkaku Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Aug 6

61 by Nah3n »»
Yesterday, 1:47 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login