1. Good production quality
- A-1 Pictures just performs exquisitely when making romance or waifu bait anime. Here, the character designs stand out and the background art visually looks great overall.
2. Subversion of ideas
- If you're a guy who likes ideas being subverted for a fresh take, this anime might be your choice. Makeine focuses on the tragic yet comedic fates of these heroines who fail to make a move on their love interests, leading them to the friend zone route.
3. Character interaction
- I'd say it's a plus for this anime thanks to Nukumizu's role as an audience's surrogate. He's witnessing the girls at their worst, so you get to find out the funny side of things instead of your usual melodrama crying from utter rejection and such. Because of that, the comedy works pretty well, even though the majority of cast existing are pretty much nutjobs.
Possible issues for Makeine:
1. Tropes are in sight
- The story is eager to explore the fates of the losing heroines, so you're also subjected to their personalities that led them to not being able to get a boyfriend in their school days. As such, they employ tropes you have found in your earlier anime-watching days. Development will come for sure, but you may have to go through a bit of uninteresting quips to find any worthy growth.
2. It's susceptible to disappointment
- When you try to pursue unique ideas, it relies on proper execution and unique storytelling. Other than making a plot for the actual romance plot to happen, this anime is diving into solely subverting the friend-zoned girls arc without any focus on other plots for a safe backseat. This means if the anime sucks at delivering it or has no more ideas left to pursue, it utterly fails on its mark.
I'm at the point of wondering if it might be a good watch or not. So far, it's looking good, you get to see heroines making more expressions than just being a losing heroine. But I'm also worried about the anime just randomly failing by the time it runs out of ideas. Let's hope for the best.
Thank you for reading.
